fbpx
facebook app symbol  twitter  linkedin  instagram 1
 
A federal judge yesterday ruled against The Tohono O’odham Nation, the San Carlos Apache Tribe and environmentalists in a lawsuit to halt work on a $10 billion transmission line being built through an area of cultural significance to the tribes. 
 

The SunZia Southwest Transmission Project will carry wind-generated electricity from New Mexico to California. The 520-mile-long powerline is the biggest U.S. electricity infrastructure undertaking since the Hoover Dam and is being lauded as "the largest clean energy project in U.S. history." Fifty miles of the line is being built through San Pedro Valley, Arizona, which holds cultural significance to the Tohono O’odham, Hopi, Zuni, and San Carlos Apache Tribes.

Never miss Indian Country’s biggest stories and breaking news. Sign up to get our reporting sent straight to your inbox every weekday morning. 
 

Tucson-based conservation groups Archaeology Southwest and the Center for Biological Diversity joined the tribes in filing the suit against the U.S. Interior Department and Bureau of Land Management this January, alleging the groups failed to comply with the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA), Administrative Procedure Act (APA), two executive orders, and President Biden’s November 30, 2022, Memorandum on Uniform Standards for Tribal Consultation for issuing Limited Notices to Proceed (LNTP)

The plaintiffs called for the project to be paused until “the Bureau of Land Management completes a “legally adequate inventory of historic properties and cultural resources that would be impacted by the project.”

The project was approved by BIA in 2015, seven years after Pattern Energy Groups Inc. applied for a right-of-way permit to construct and operate the line. Construction began in 2023. 

The suit alleged that the U.S. Interior Department refused to recognize “overwhelming evidence of the cultural significance” of the remote San Pedro Valley to Native American tribes in the region. Plaintiffs alleged the project will cause “serious, irreversible adverse effects on tribal cultural sites and sacred areas, including areas with human remains.”

In her ruling, Judge Jennifer Zipps cites the San Pedro Valley as “one of the most culturally intact landscapes in southern Arizona.” She wrote that BLM had fulfilled its legal obligation to identify historic sites in the construction area and prepare an inventory of cultural resources. 

Because SunZia’s route was finalized in 2015, the judge ruled the tribe’s injunction was “time-barred.”  

BLM asserts that the project, which is 90 percent completed, avoids direct impacts on cultural resources identified by surveys. 

Tohono O’odham Nation stated in a press release that it will continue to pursue legal avenues to protect their land. 

“Our goal is not only to protect our ancestorial cultural history and the San Pedro River Valley’s pristine environment, but to also ensure the federal government is held accountable for its actions in violation of laws designed specifically to protect sacred lands,” Tohono O’odham Nation Chairman Verlon Jose said in a statement. "This is far too important of an issue to be deterred by this ruling. The United States’ renewable energy policy that includes destroying sacred and undeveloped landscapes is fundamentally wrong and must stop.”

This article has been updated to include a statement from the Tohono O’odham Nation.

More Stories Like This

Washington Tribes Get $39M to Restore Salmon Habitat
Navajo Nation Urges Biden to Halt Uranium Transportation Through Its Lands
Navajo Nation Agreement to Settle All Water Rights Claims in Arizona 
Biden Expands Two National Monuments in California by 120,000 Acres
Sault Tribe Joins the Fight for Mother Nature’s Legal Rights with New Resolution

These stories must be heard.

This May, we are highlighting our coverage of Indian boarding schools and their generational impact on Native families and Native communities. Giving survivors of boarding schools and their descendants the opportunity to share their stories is an important step toward healing — not just because they are speaking, but because they are being heard. Their stories must be heard. Help our efforts to make sure Native stories and Native voices are heard in 2024. Please consider a recurring donation to help fund our ongoing coverage of Indian boarding schools. Donate to Native News Online today and support independent Indigenous-centered journalism. Thank you.

About The Author
Author: Elyse WildEmail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Elyse Wild is senior editor for Native News Online and Tribal Business News.