fbpx
facebook app symbol  twitter  linkedin  instagram 1
 
A first-of-its-kind report confirms what tribal nations have long argued: federal policy changes and funding are critical to combat the fentanyl crisis disproportionately claiming Native American lives.
 
Fentanyl, a highly lethal illicit opioid 100 times more potent than morphine, drove nearly 75,000 overdose deaths in 2023 — about 70% of all overdoses, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. While total overdoses nationwide dropped that year, they increased among Native Americans.
 
Published last month by the Brookings Institution, “The Impact of Fentanyl on American Indian and Alaska Native Communities” examines the systemic causes behind the high rates of opioid overdoses in Indigenous communities: mismanaged public safety on tribal lands, limited access to healthcare, and high incarceration rates of Native people. The 32-page report highlights Native-led solutions already reducing deaths in tribal communities.
 
The report’s executive summary leads with a statement dispelling a long-standing stereotype about Native Americans and addiction: “There is no evidence of genetic predisposition to opioid use disorder. Instead, the AI/AN populations’ vulnerability to fentanyl harms can be traced to historical and contemporary policy failures and ongoing theft of AI/AN resources.”
 
Philomena Kebec J.D., Brookings Institution Fellow“The drunken Indian stereotype has followed us into the opioid crisis,” says the report's author Philomena Kebec. Such stereotypes obscure the real drivers of the crisis. 
Philomena Kebec (Bad River Band of Lake Superior Chippewa Indians), an attorney and fellow at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health who authored the report, told Native News Online it was crucial to address the false notion that Native people are prone to addiction. 
 

“The drunken Indian stereotype has followed us into the opioid crisis,” Kebec said. Such stereotypes obscure the real drivers of the crisis.  

“It’s a policy question, it’s a resource question, it’s a historical trauma question. We, as American Indian people, have a common experience of American-style colonization,” Kebec said. 

The real-world impacts of these systemic issues are further masked by data-collection practices.

Widely practiced data suppression policies — excluding data when incident numbers are too low — obscure the full scope of Native American overdose deaths. That creates an incomplete national picture, Kebec said. 

With billions in opioid settlement money flowing to states and federal addiction care funding rising, tribal nations need dedicated resources and improved data collection.  

“Tribal communities often know what the solutions are,” Kebec said. “They don’t necessarily need that research. But if we’re talking about national-level strategies, we absolutely need research to help guide us in creating and investing in the solutions that are going to work for these communities.”

Public Law 280

While drug deaths among Native Americans are twice as high as the national average, some states show even starker disparities. Minnesota and Wisconsin report the nation’s worst overdose mortality rates for Native people, the report finds. Both are mandatory Public Law 280 states, where the states, not the federal government, have criminal jurisdiction over reservations. 

In states that adopted Public Law 280 mandatorily or optionally, tribal land policing has been underfunded for decades. Most report high Native overdose rates, Kebec notes.

“This phenomenon is happening within Wisconsin and Minnesota and other places affected by Public Law 280,” she said. “That is noteworthy. I think that is something we need to continue to dig into.”

Not all the disparities in fentanyl-related deaths can be attributed to Public Law 280, Kebec acknowledges, but the contrast between neighboring Great Lakes states is instructive. Michigan and Wisconsin share similar Native population numbers and political climates, yet Michigan’s Native American overdose was 16 per 100,000 in 2022, compared to Wisconsin’s 65 per 100,000. 

Minnesota’s Native American overdose rate of 145 per 100,000 ranks third nationally, behind only Arizona and Oklahoma.

Never miss Indian Country’s biggest stories and breaking news. Sign up to get our reporting sent straight to your inbox every weekday morning. 

Sen. Tina Smith (D-Minn.) told Native News Online that the numbers reflect both public safety gaps and limited healthcare resources in tribal communities. 

“It also is emblematic of the challenges tribes have getting the resources to provide all the different levels of care that are culturally connected to their members,” Smith said. “We know when tribes have the autonomy and when they have the resources, they’re able to get after these issues.”

Last month, Smith introduced legislation that would expand the Special Tribal Criminal Jurisdiction (STCJ) program to allow tribal nations to prosecute non-Native offenders for drug crimes. Her push came after discussions with tribal leaders in Minnesota about drug trafficking on reservations and how Public Law 280 leaves tribes at a loss when prosecuting non-tribal offenders.

“[They] laid out for me both the devastation of opioids and increasingly fentanyl on tribal lands,” Smith said. “And the incredible devastation of tribes as they see this revolving door of non-native people coming on tribal lands, selling drugs, committing crimes, and then the inability of tribal leaders to be able to get after those folks.”

But enforcement requires nuance, Kebec said, noting that prosecution laws may unintentionally deter people in Native communities from calling emergency services if they witness an overdose.

“We’re creating perverse incentives for people not to call 911, and oftentimes in these communities, we’re not giving those folks the support to also interrupt an overdose on their own,” Kebec said.

Solutions and Treatment

Beyond public safety issues, the Brookings report examines access barriers to FDA-approved medications to treat opioid addiction: buprenorphine, methadone, and naltrexone. While these medications can cut opioid death risk by half, only a handful of tribal nations have programs to distribute them.

Yet tribes are developing innovative, culturally-centered solutions highlighted in the report.  The White Earth Nation in northwestern Minnesota created a treatment framework that centers on Anishinaabe values and the circular concept of time.  In Oregon, the Confederated Tribes of Grand Ronde launched a mobile unit that delivers medication to treat opioid addiction on the remote reservation.

Kebec co-founded the Gwayakobimaadiziwin Exchange Program from her garage on the Bad River Reservation in 2015. Today, the needle exchange program, which operates on a $1 million budget, distributes naloxone and harm reduction supplies across four counties bordering the reservation. 

Now pursuing her doctorate in public health at Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Kebec remains steadfast in her commitment to reducing overdose deaths in Indian Country. 

“This is something that we can overcome,” she said. “Overdose fatalities are not inevitable. There are many solutions that we can come up with.  This is not theoretical. This is not just an academic exercise. For me, I’m absolutely invested in this.”

More Stories Like This

San Manuel Band of Mission Indians Awards $100,000 Grant to Support Native News Online's Health Equity Coverage
The Importance of Handwashing
Indian Health Service and Chickasaw Nation to Sign Joint Venture Agreement and Lease for Newcastle Medical Center
Q&A: Angela Gonzales (Hopi), on New Indigenous Health Research Dashboard

About The Author
Elyse Wild
Author: Elyse WildEmail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Senior Health Editor
Elyse Wild is Senior Health Editor for Native News Online, where she leads coverage of health equity issues including mental health, environmental health, maternal mortality, and the overdose crisis in Indian Country. Her award-winning journalism has appeared in The Guardian, McClatchy newspapers, and NPR affiliates. In 2024, she received the inaugural Excellence in Recovery Journalism Award for her solutions-focused reporting on addiction and recovery in Native communities. She is currently working on a Pulitzer Center-funded series exploring cultural approaches to addiction treatment.