On Friday, June 24, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 2-1 that a copper mine in Arizona can proceed with operations while a lawsuit filed by Apache Stronghold is pending. Resolution Copper, a joint venture between Rio Tinto and BHP—both mining companies from Australia—plans to develop one of the largest undeveloped copper deposits in the world near a site that some Apache believe is sacred. 

 The copper deposit is located within the Tonto National Forest and its transfer was authorized by an act of Congress, the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) of 2014. The bill required the government to exchange the land and allow the mine to be built. 

In its lawsuit against the U.S., Apache Stronghold, a nonprofit organization, argued that the 2,422 acres of land the U.S. government exchanged to Resolution Copper includes a ceremonial ground called Chichʼil Bildagoteel, known as “Oak Flat.” 

The federal court ruled that the land exchange would not violate Tribal members’ religious freedom protections under the U.S. Constitution or the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, a 1993 religious liberty law, as Apache Stronghold’s lawsuit contends. 

Never miss Indian Country’s biggest stories and breaking news. Sign up to get our reporting sent straight to your inbox every weekday morning. 

“The Department of Agriculture will simply transfer ownership of a plot of government land to Resolution Copper, and the Land Exchange does not coerce the Apache to abandon their religion by threatening them with a negative outcome,” wrote Judge Carlos Bea in Friday’s decision. Chief Judge Mary Murguia agreed.

Mining was banned at Oak Flat until 2014, after the NDAA was passed, but the land exchange faced several hurdles over the years: It was nearly completed towards the end of the Trump administration, but was halted due to Apache Stronghold’s lawsuit, which is still pending. The Biden administration rescinded the approval for the land exchange, in hopes for more tribal consultation. 

Dr. Wendsler Nosie, Sr., former Tribal Chairman for the San Carlos Apache Tribe and a spokesperson for Apache Stronghold said in a statement that the organization will appeal the ruling to the U.S. Supreme Court. “Oak Flat is like Mount Sinai to us, our most sacred site where we connect with our Creation, our faith, our families and our land.,” he said. 

Judge Marsha Berzon, who voted against the 2-1 majority, wrote that transferring the site to Resolution Copper would destroy Oak Flat and, therefore, eliminate the possibility of holding ceremonies there. The transfer would “make the site inaccessible and eventually destroy it, objectively preventing Apaches from holding religious ceremonies there,” she wrote. 

“As we reach this conclusion, we do not rejoice. Rather, we recognize the deep ties that the Apache have to Oak Flat and to the nearby Apache Leap and Devil’s Canyon,” wrote Bea on behalf of the court. “And we acknowledge that the Land Exchange may impact the Apache’s plans to worship on Oak Flat. But RFRA, the Free Exercise Clause, and the 1852 Treaty of Santa Fe do not afford Apache Stronghold the relief that it seeks. This dispute must be resolved as are most others in our pluralistic nation: through the political process.”

More Stories Like This

Sicangu Lakota Treaty Council Attending White House Summit on Building Climate Resilient Communities
'We want the fences to come down' | $5M for Buffalo Restoration Focuses on Wrong Area, Advocacy Group Says
Over 60 Tribes Support Michigan Attorney General's Lawsuit to Close Enbridge's Line 5
Three California Tribal Nations Declare First U.S. Indigenous Marine Stewardship Area
“No Green Colonialism: Land Back NOW!” Mural in NYC's Times Square Demands Real Solutions

Stand with us in championing Indigenous journalism that makes a difference. Your support matters.

Support our Indigenous-led newsroom as we shed light on critical issues, such as the painful history of Indian Boarding Schools. To date, we've published nearly 200 stories dedicated to this important topic, providing insights and awareness to a global audience. Our news is freely accessible to all, but its production demands resources. That's why we're reaching out to you this month for your generous contribution.

For those who commit to a recurring donation of $12 per month or more, or make a one-time donation of $150 or greater, we're excited to offer you a copy of our upcoming Indian Boarding School publication. Additionally, you will be added to our Founder's Circle. Together, we can ensure that these vital stories continue to be told, shared, and remembered.

About The Author
Author: Darren ThompsonEmail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Darren Thompson (Lac du Flambeau Ojibwe) is a staff reporter for Native News Online who is based in the Twin Cities of Minnesota. Thompson has reported on political unrest, tribal sovereignty, and Indigenous issues for the Aboriginal Peoples Television Network, Indian Country Today, Native News Online, Powwows.com and Unicorn Riot. He has contributed to the New York Times, the Washington Post, and Voice of America on various Indigenous issues in international conversation. He has a bachelor’s degree in Criminology & Law Studies from Marquette University in Milwaukee, Wisconsin.