U.S. Capitol (Photo/Levi Rickert for Native News Online)

Overview:

Tribal leaders say federal agencies are treating consultation as a formality, sidelining sovereign nations from decisions affecting their lands and funding.

The Nov. 3 election brought historic victories for Native candidates, including the election of the first Native woman to the U.S. Senate. But as Congress meets for its lame-duck session, Tribal nations face a familiar question: Who in Washington is listening — and who is willing to change federal policy after hearing what Tribal leaders have to say?

Tribal consultation was designed to provide a mechanism for government-to-government dialogue on federal policies that affect their nations. President Bill Clinton strengthened federal tribal consultation policy through Executive Order 13175, signed on Nov. 6, 2000.

The intention was never to make tribal consultation a performative exercise. It was never meant to be a box-checking function carried out by a bureaucrat. For Indian Country, tribal consultation is rooted in tribal sovereignty and the government-to-government relationship that comes with it.

Tohono O’odham Nation Chairman Verlon Jose recounted an incident that occurred on Aug. 25, 2026, when a caravan of construction workers attempted to enter the Tohono O’odham Nation but was turned away by tribal police. The workers were there to conduct pre-construction work for a proposed 62-mile border wall that President Donald Trump wants to build through the Tohono O’odham Nation’s reservation with Mexico — a project the tribal nation adamantly opposes.

Undeterred, the construction crew returned in the middle of the night, accompanied by Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) police and a Border Patrol tactical team

At 4:03 a.m., Chairman Jose received a call from a tribal citizen informing him that the caravan was already on tribal land and heading south. At 4:58 a.m., his email notification sounded. It was a message from a federal official informing him that a crew would be arriving to conduct pre-construction work.

“I forgot to let you know that we’re going to be coming out to the nation to do pre-construction work,” the email read.

“They were already here. He didn’t even know that,” Chairman Jose said in an interview with Native News Online. “They had the nerve to call that tribal consultation.”

An email announcing work underway is notification after the fact. It is not meaningful tribal consultation. 

Last week, Tribal leaders called into question another so-called tribal consultation, this time conducted by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB).

On Nov. 4, OMB Director Russell Vought, one of the primary architects of Project 2025, issued a Dear Tribal Leaders letter announcing consultations for Nov. 9 in Washington, D.C., and Nov. 10 virtually. The notice gave Tribal Nations just two days to register and a few days to prepare for the consultation. 

At issue were proposed revisions to Title 2 of the Code of Federal Regulations (2 CFR), known as the Uniform Guidance for Federal Financial Assistance.

These rules govern how agencies award federal funds and how recipients, including tribal governments, manage the money and account for its use.

The five-day notice, which included two weekend days, gave Tribal Nations little opportunity to properly review the proposal, consult with their tribal councils and legal advisers, determine its potential impact on their governments and prepare meaningful responses.

The National Congress of American Indians (NCAI) called the notice period unacceptable and said the process did not constitute meaningful tribal consultation.

NCAI Executive Director Larry Wright Jr. (Ponca) described what happened during the consultation sessions on Native News Online’s Post-Election Recap Livestream (Part 2).

Wright said the Nov. 9 in-person session drew about 20 attendees but lasted only 22 minutes, with four people speaking.  He called the treatment of elected tribal officials “shameful.” 

“When you’re talking about true meaningful consultation you can’t do that in a three-minute soundbite,” he said. 

The Nov. 10 virtual session drew more than 200 attendees and included 25 speakers over 90 minutes, Wright said.  Federal officials cut off 20 speakers at the three-minute mark, sometimes speaking over them. 

“It was pathetic,” Wright said.

Cherokee Nation Principal Chief Chuck Hoskin Jr., another guest on the video consultation, also weighed in.

“The problem is the train’s been leaving the station on these rules and regs before tribes are brought in,” Hoskin said. “We can actually help the government be better and do better, but we’ve got to be in the room when they’re hashing out these plans.” 

The federal government cannot respect sovereignty only when doing so is convenient. Consultation requires time for tribal governments to respond and a willingness by federal officials to change course. 

The incoming 120th Congress offers an opportunity to insist on that standard. In the meantime, the question remains: Who’s listening to tribal nations in Washington?

Thayék gde nwéndëmen – we are all related.

Levi “Calm Before the Storm” Rickert (Prairie Band Potawatomi Nation) is the founder, publisher, and editor of Native News Online. Rickert was awarded the Best Column Award in the print/online category...