Overview:
Traci Morris, a Chickasaw citizen and researcher at Arizona State University’s Sandra Day O’Connor College of Law, is advancing the concept of tribal digital sovereignty, helping Native nations assert self-determination and control over the technologies, digital infrastructure and data that affect their communities.
Traci Morris said she loves to be at the cutting edge of emerging technologies while supporting First American tribes within that space. Her research and scholarship regarding tribal digital sovereignty links both loves together.
When most people think about sovereignty, they think about governance of land, people and institutions. However, now there is a new digital landscape that also needs governing. Morris, a Chickasaw citizen, works tirelessly through her publications and professional work at the Tribal Nations Policy Institute in the Sandra Day O’Connor College of Law at Arizona State University to ensure tribal nations can exercise their own self-determination over the existing and emerging digital world.
“I think we are going to be moving more from cybersecurity as an IT concern to sovereignty as a concern,” Morris said. “Any nation that can’t defend its systems can’t guarantee its services. So it’s more than just cybersecurity — it’s cyber sovereignty.”
Morris said ideas about digital sovereignty originated with the European Union (EU). When she was conducting research for a book about tribal broadband internet, Morris kept coming across the term “digital sovereignty” and something clicked for her.
“One day I went, ‘We’re tribes. We’re sovereign,’” Morris said. “I saw that they were talking about governance, and tribes have the ability to govern. I thought, ‘We can have tribal digital sovereignty.’”
Morris used the language the EU had been using to govern its own digital spaces and transformed it as a concept applicable to tribal nations. She said she had seen the EU create rigid structures and rules technology companies would have to adhere to. These rules go beyond the EU, often having a global effect. Morris noted, for instance, when people have to opt in on websites to allow tracking cookies, that rule came from strict EU guidelines.
“I invented the term as a way to talk overarchingly about exerting a sort of sovereign governance over digital spaces,” Morris said. “We can govern our spaces. We as sovereign nations can say what is on our land.” She said digital spaces are no different.
Morris started talking about tribal digital sovereignty at conferences and was encouraged by the response. She said many tribal and community leaders immediately understood the importance of what she was presenting.
The digital realm over which tribal nations have sovereignty includes all the technology that touches people’s lives. Morris said broadband internet and other related infrastructure lay the foundation for this digital landscape.
“It starts with whether or not internet works at your house,” Morris said. “Whether or not a student can do homework without having to drive to a parking lot for a signal. Whether or not an elder can use telehealth instead of driving two hours.”
According to Morris, broadband infrastructure is the most visible layer of the digital world, but deeper than that is data or information.
“There are two layers because we are a tribal nation,” Morris explained. “It’s the data that the tribe is protecting — whether it’s gaming data or data about our citizen enrollment — those are all proprietary and belong to our nation. But personally, it’s your enrollment records, your school data, your health records — those sorts of things. So tribal digital sovereignty is who decides what happens to that data.”
Beyond infrastructure and data is the ability of tribal nations to protect their own knowledge.
“Digital sovereignty also affects whether, and how, our knowledge stays with us,” Morris said. “So much of our information, our communities and our tribes have been taken from us, and digital and data sovereignty is how a nation sets its rules and takes care of it.”
Morris noted, in particular, the creation of Chickasaw TV for uploading videos about the Chickasaw Nation. Because the Chickasaw Nation has its own platform, it can govern how the information is seen, used and protected.
Chickasaw TV also allows the Chickasaw Nation to retain ownership and copyright protection over its content. For instance, Morris said if someone posts a ceremony on YouTube or Facebook, that knowledge is out there forever, and it cannot be pulled back. Having its own platforms allows the Chickasaw Nation to guard and protect tribal knowledge and heritage.
Morris hosted a conference last year on AI in Indian Country. Mari Hulbutta, director of data stewardship for the Chickasaw Nation, was on a panel and said, “Data is kin.”
“You could have heard a pin drop,” Morris said.
Morris said Hulbutta’s statement has stuck with her.
“Data is kin,” Morris stated. “How do we protect our kin? What do we do to take care of our kin? Why are we not doing that with our data?”
Morris said she is proud of how the Chickasaw Nation has approached this new digital realm as it protects the data and knowledge of its culture and citizens, while also providing critical infrastructure. However, Morris also looks toward the future, especially because technology changes come in months, not years.
“I definitely see it changing quick enough that right now, we are at a great point because everybody’s in the same boat,” Morris said. “Every community, the whole nation, everybody in the world is like, ‘What are we going to do? Are we going to regulate it? What does this look like?’”
Morris is the executive director of the Tribal Nations Policy Institute at the Sandra Day O’Connor College of Law at Arizona State University. With her position, as well as her specialized knowledge, Morris is able to help tribal nations across the country, making sure tribes have the information and the time to understand the new developments, which sometimes seem to manifest overnight.
“We, as individuals and as tribal nations, have the agency to make our own decisions and govern these spaces,” Morris said. “That’s such a powerful thing that people need to know.”
