The SunZia Wind and Transmission Project took nearly two decades to reach operation. Sen. Martin Heinrich has cited that timeline in arguing for faster permitting, a goal of the proposed Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. (Photo/Johannes Plenio)

Overview:

Tribal Nations and preservation advocates are fiercely opposing the fast-tracked Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) because its permitting reforms—written behind closed doors without tribal input—would strip away vital protections for sacred lands by narrowing required consultations, slashing legal challenge timelines, and preventing courts from halting unlawful energy projects.

On the night of September 30, 2026, phones across Indian Country began lighting up with alerts and frantic text messages. Late that afternoon, the Senate had dropped the 400-page Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA). A sweeping reform bill, its sponsors say it would speed approval and permitting of energy and infrastructure projects, expand electric transmission and help lower energy costs. 

But for Tribes and preservation advocates, the bill contained a number of poison pills that would put their sovereignty and lands at risk. At issue: Title III of the bill would amend Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act, the provision that requires federal agencies to consider a project’s effects on historic properties and consult with Tribes when places of religious or cultural significance to them may be affected. 

The proposed legislation would also weaken protections under the National Environmental Policy Act, limiting which projects receive review and how agencies assess their potential effects on water quality, air quality, wildlife and nearby communities. 

Sen. Shelley Moore Capito (R-W.Va.) introduced BAAJA with cosponsors Sens. Martin Heinrich (D-NM), Mike Lee (R-Utah) and Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.), the chairs and ranking members of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources and Environment and Public Works committees. 

In addition to restricting required consultations, Title III would also reduce the six-year statute of limitations for NHPA challenges to a 150-day deadline for filing suit, narrow who could bring those challenges and sharply limiting courts’ remedies—while allowing construction to continue even after a judge found that an agency had violated the law. 

Without warning, tribes were now confronted with one of the most aggressive threats to their sovereignty since the Removal Era. Moreover, the proposed rewrite of Section 106 of the NHPA moved forward on a bipartisan basis and fast-tracked without Tribal consultation or hearings on the bill—a troubling departure from established legislative practice. 

“It’s thorough and surgical—they knew exactly what they were doing. It was such perfectly engineered legislation designed to strip tribes of their statutory protections that I can’t believe this is happening in 2026,” says a tribal advocate who asked for anonymity to candidly discuss the bill’s impact on tribes. “They dropped it at the last minute before the elections as a big ‘screw you’ to Indian Country in a move so shocking in its scope of harm that it will take generations to undo if it passes as is.”

In fact, every major organization in Indian Country has come out in fierce opposition to the bill, including the National Congress of American Indians, the Native American Rights Fund, the National Association of Tribal Historic Preservation Officers, and the Association of American Indian Affairs, among others, urging Congress to remove Title III or halt the bill altogether. 

Heinrich’s Big, Beautiful Permitting Reform Bill 

Sen. Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.) is the ranking member of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee, which oversees national energy policy, public lands, the Department of Energy, and nuclear-waste policy. 

Heinrich championed the SunZia wind farm project in New Mexico that has been billed as the largest renewable energy infrastructure project in the Western Hemisphere.

On June 18, 2026, after nearly two decades of delays, litigation and tribal opposition, the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee (ENR) published a press release announcing that the SunZia project was fully operational and highlighted its expected energy and economic benefits for New Mexico. 

The announcement, however, did not mention ongoing litigation brought by the Tohono O’odham Nation, the San Carlos Apache Tribe and other plaintiffs, who allege that construction of SunZia’s transmission lines harmed the San Pedro Valley in Arizona and that federal agencies failed to consult adequately with the tribes. 

In both the press release and in his remarks to the Los Angeles Times at the time, Heinrich pointedly failed to mention the tribes as stakeholders and obliquely referred to “the need for permitting reform” and approval process for future energy projects.  

According to tribal leaders, both in his home state of New Mexico and across the country, at no time did Heinrich mention that he and his co-sponsors had been working for over a year with various staffers and energy lobbyists to develop this legislation. A tense meeting on October 23rd between Heinrich and the All Pueblo Council of Governors ended in less than 15 minutes after Heinrich flatly refused to remove or amend Title III.

In a November 7th editorial in the Santa Fe New Mexican, Laguna Pueblo Governor Harry A. Antonio Jr., responded by demanding that Congress reject BAAJA and consult with Tribal governments to protect water rights and sacred places like Chaco Canyon.

Notably, campaign-finance records show that in March 2026, Martin Heinrich for Senate received a $5,000 personal contribution from SunZia’s parent company, Pattern Energy Group LP CEO Hunter Armistead and a separate $5,000 contribution from Pattern PAC. Both went to Heinrich’s campaign, three months before SunZia was announced as fully operational. The PAC had previously contributed $12,000 to Heinrich’s campaign in 2018, 2023 and 2024. Heinrich is not up for reelection until 2030. 

On the Precipice

On Monday, November 16th, the U.S. Senate voted 70-27 to end debate on a managers’ amendment that would have strengthened provisions of the bill addressing data centers and protected tribal sovereignty, moving the bill closer to a final vote. The Senate is expected to take up another procedural vote on Wednesday.

“The Senate took another disappointing step toward passing a misguided bill that strips Tribal Nations of our rights in order to make it easier to build pipelines, data centers, strip mines, wind farms, and other projects,” said Ira L. Matt, executive director of the National Association of Tribal Historic Preservation Officers (NATHPO). 

“This bill, written behind closed doors and without consulting Tribal Nations, needlessly undermines our rights to be consulted on our sacred places and how best to protect them. Once these places are bulldozed, they cannot be restored, and Senators should heed the calls to slow down, remove the historic preservation title, and craft new language in a transparent process that includes Tribal consultation.”

Contained within this sprawling legislation is a rewrite of Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act. Tribal preservation advocates say it would gut tribal authority by narrowing the effects of projects subject to review, and changing the definition of what qualifies as a “property of traditional religious or cultural importance.” As introduced, S. 5653 defines it as an identifiable place or feature where “an event of continuing religious or cultural significance to a living community occurred.”  

Under the bill, agencies could move forward if tribes or other consulting parties failed to respond to a specific report or finding within 30 days, or if their objections were deemed not “substantive”—a standard the bill does not define.

The bill would also sharply limit remedies for violations of the act. Courts could order agencies to address legal deficiencies, but generally could not halt, nullify or even issue injunctions on projects already under construction.

“We are sovereign nations, and we need to be able to participate in the analyses and offer information to say that what you’re proposing might not be the best idea, and here’s why,” said Daniel Cordalis (Navajo Nation), staff attorney of the Native American Rights Fund. “There have been no hearings on the bill and no real opportunity to gather stakeholder input. We’re trying to tell people that leaving the tribes out of the process doesn’t work and it’s just going to lead to bad decisions that will be challengeable in court.”  

Finally, BAAJA would route any NHPA challenges—and related claims under other laws arising from the same project—directly to federal courts of appeals, bypassing the opportunity to build meaningful cases through trial-level fact-finding expertise. 

“Legally, it restructures the entire way we normally do things. District courts and courts of appeal have very different functions in our judicial system and this proposal completely undermines the structure that allows us to pursue meaningful justice,” said a policy analyst on Capitol Hill who asked for anonymity to freely discuss the impacts of the legislation. “Even if someone is able to get through those systemic barriers and long wait times, the courts can’t even issue an injunction to halt illegally permitted or potentially dangerous projects. Our hands are tied and our voices are muted. This is catastrophic legislation.”

While Tribes typically have a government-to-government relationship with the federal government, they were completely left out of the drafting process. That they were only notified when it was presented to them as a finished package at the last minute was a very telling strategy on the part of the sponsors and writers of BAAJA.

“Dropping it on September 30, then ramming it through a confusing, fast-tracked process—often without even allowing discussion from their own colleagues—leaves tribes almost no meaningful chance to have a voice in matters that directly affect them,” said the analyst. “That’s a pretty big slap in the face.”