- Details
Most drivers believe they understand how car insurance works. After all, they pay their premiums, carry what they’re told is “enough coverage,” and assume the system will take care of them if something goes wrong.
Then an accident happens, and the surprises start.
Across the country, we see the same misconceptions play out over and over. They’re not reckless mistakes. They’re myths people accept as fact, often passed down by friends, social media, or outdated advice. Unfortunately, these myths can turn a manageable accident into a long-term financial problem.
Here are some of the most common car insurance myths that end up costing Americans thousands after a crash.
Myth #1: “The Other Driver’s Insurance Will Cover Everything”
This is probably the most expensive assumption drivers make.
In theory, the at-fault driver’s insurance should pay. In practice, that coverage is often limited. Many drivers carry only the minimum insurance required by their state, and those limits can be surprisingly low. A single emergency room visit, diagnostic testing, or short hospital stay can wipe out a policy fast.
Even when coverage exists, payouts don’t happen overnight. Claims are investigated, liability can be disputed, and payments may come long after bills are due.
The reality is that fault doesn’t guarantee full compensation. It only determines whose policy is supposed to respond and how much that policy can actually pay.
Myth #2: “I Have Health Insurance, So I’m Fine”
Health insurance helps, but it doesn’t make you whole after a car accident.
Medical coverage usually comes with deductibles, co-pays, and network restrictions. Follow-up care, physical therapy, or specialized treatment may not be fully covered. Some services are denied outright. Others are approved only after delays.
Health insurance also doesn’t replace lost income, cover transportation costs, or account for the way injuries affect daily life. In many cases, health insurers may later seek reimbursement from any accident-related recovery, adding another layer of complexity that drivers don’t expect.
Relying on health insurance alone often leaves people paying far more out of pocket than they planned.
Myth #3: “You Can’t File a Car Accident Claim Without a Police Report”
A police report is helpful, but it’s not always required to pursue an insurance claim.
Many accidents happen in parking lots, on private property, or minor collisions where police don’t respond. In other cases, drivers are told to exchange information and move on. Waiting for a report that never comes can delay a claim unnecessarily.
What often matters more is documentation: photos of the scene, vehicle damage, witness information, and medical records showing when symptoms began.
That said, rules vary by state and insurer, and there are situations where a police report becomes very important. The key point is that the absence of one doesn’t automatically eliminate your options, but waiting too long because of this myth can.
Myth #4: “If It’s Not My Fault, I Don’t Need to Worry”
Many drivers assume that being “not at fault” means they can relax. Unfortunately, fault is rarely as simple as it feels at the scene.
Insurance companies investigate accidents independently. Statements, photos, vehicle damage, and witness accounts all play a role. In some states, comparative fault rules mean that even partial responsibility can reduce what a driver recovers.
It’s also common for fault to shift over time as more information comes in. What feels obvious immediately after a crash may be challenged weeks later.
Being careful early on matters, even when you’re confident you didn’t cause the accident.
Myth #5: “If the At-Fault Driver Has No Insurance, There’s Nothing I Can Do”
This myth is especially damaging and increasingly common.
Uninsured and underinsured drivers are on the road in every state. When one of them causes a crash, many people assume they’re out of luck. In reality, many policies include uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage designed for exactly this situation.
The problem is that drivers often don’t know they have this coverage, don’t understand how it works, or assume it doesn’t apply if they weren’t at fault. Others decline it entirely to save money, without realizing how exposed that decision leaves them.
When the at-fault driver can’t pay, your own policy may be the only financial protection available. Not knowing that ahead of time can turn a bad accident into a personal financial crisis.
Why These Myths Stick Around
Car insurance policies are dense, technical, and rarely read line by line. Most people learn how insurance works secondhand until an accident forces them to learn it the hard way.
Stress also plays a role. After a crash, people want to believe things will resolve quickly and fairly. Assumptions feel easier than digging into policy language while dealing with injuries, travel disruptions, or work obligations.
Unfortunately, insurance doesn’t operate on assumptions. It operates on coverage details.
What Drivers Can Do Instead
You don’t need to become an insurance expert to protect yourself, but a few habits make a real difference:
- Don’t assume coverage limits are enough—review them periodically
- Document accidents early, even if they seem minor
- Be cautious with recorded statements made under pressure
- Understand that delays and disputes are part of the process
Most costly mistakes happen early, before drivers realize what’s at stake.
The Bottom Line
Car accidents don’t just test your reflexes. They test your assumptions. Many of the biggest financial losses we see don’t come from reckless driving, but from believing insurance myths that simply aren’t true.
Knowing how coverage actually works won’t prevent an accident. But it can prevent a temporary setback from becoming a long-term problem.
And that knowledge, in the end, is far cheaper than learning the hard way.