The fight for answers does not end when a loved one passes. For many Indigenous families, it can become a yearslong struggle to navigate law enforcement agencies, complicated jurisdictions and a system that too often leaves them without the information they need.
That reality is at the center of She Cried That Day, a documentary by filmmaker Amanda Erickson, a citizen of the San Carlos Apache Tribe. The film follows the family of Dione Thomas, who died in 2015 at a motel in Gallup, New Mexico, and their ongoing efforts to understand what happened.
Erickson joins Native News Online’s Native Bidaské livestream to discuss the documentary, her connection to the story and the broader Missing and Murdered Indigenous People (MMIP) crisis.
In the episode, Erickson explains that the documentary began as a personal effort for Erickson, who grew up on the East Coast, separated from her father and Apache relatives. After reconnecting with her father, she attended an Apache Sunrise Ceremony, a coming-of-age ceremony for young Apache women.
After nearly 20 years working as a television producer in New York, primarily covering true crime, Erickson began looking for ways to use her filmmaking experience to give back to Indigenous communities.
As awareness of the crisis of missing and murdered Indigenous women grew, she focused her research on New Mexico, where she said the state had the highest number of cases at the time. At a task force meeting, she heard Dione’s sister, Christine, speak about her family’s experience. That meeting led Erickson to the story.
In the documentary, viewers see how Dione’s family has worked to get answers about her death. According to Erickson, Dione’s death was initially classified as undetermined, despite multiple police calls to the motel room that day following reports of fighting and yelling.
The family has faced years of uncertainty while trying to navigate the agencies and jurisdictions involved in the case. Dione’s sister Christine and mother Debbie initially led the effort to seek answers. Her sister Karen has since stepped forward to continue that work.
“She Cried That Day” is streaming on PBS through Nov. 29. Watch here.
Viewers can learn more about the documentary at shecriedthatday.com.
Watch Native Bidaské with Amanda Erickson on Friday, November 20th, at 12 p.m. ET on Facebook, YouTube, NativeNewsOnline.net, and TikTok.
