Navajo President Tells NM Lawmakers Proposed Gaming Compact Infringes on Sovereignty

COC.NN PresidentSANTA FE – For the second time in as many weeks, Navajo President Ben Shelly presented the Navajo Nation Gaming Compact to the New Mexico Legislature Committee on Compacts at the state’s Roundhouse on January 31, 2014.

President Shelly said it was important for the Committee on Compacts to be well informed regarding the Navajo Nation Gaming Compact because their decision would have a major impact on the tribal economy and jobs.

He spoke about the geographic restrictions raised by other tribal leaders at the first meeting a week earlier.

“At the last committee hearing, several tribal leaders raised concerns on the future locations for the Navajo Nation’s gaming facilities along the I-40 corridor and Albuquerque area,” President Shelly said. “While I respect the recommendations from the other tribes, the Navajo Nation will not agree to any geographic restriction.”

He said the provision infringed upon Navajo sovereignty and cited three reasons why the Nation will not agree to the geographic restriction provision.

It is the Navajo Nation’s inherent right to develop and pursue any economic venture on our tribal trust lands, he said.

President Shelly said with over 50 percent unemployment on the Nation, any restriction on tribal economic development is not only unfair, but also immoral.

He noted that the geographic restrictions are in violation of the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, commonly known as IGRA, and that the Department of the Interior would not approve such a provision.

Case in point is the August 2013 opinion from DOI regarding the Menominee Tribe, which stated that IGRA does not grant an affirmative right for any nearby tribes to be free from economic competition.

In response to comments that gaming facilities should compete with outside gaming industries such a s Las Vegas, President Shelly said the Navajo Nation Gaming Compact does adopt additional industry standards that meet the Nation’s needs.

The two main provisions in the industry standards would allow the Nation’s gaming facilities to be open 24 hours a day, seven days a week; and that food and drinks would be available at a reduced rate under the player’s club program.

The third issue raised by President Shelly was in regard to the timeline for the approval of the gaming compact.

“During the last hearing, a tribal leader requested that the Navajo Nation Gaming Compact be tabled. We cannot endure further delay. We are on a very strict timeline to extend the term of the compact before it expires in 2015,” President Shelly said.

Upon approval by the Committee on Compacts, the Navajo Nation Gaming Compact would still need to be moved to the floor of the House and Senate for vote. After the New Mexico Legislature’s approval, the compact would be sent to the Department of the Interior’s Indian Affairs for final approval in accordance with IGRA.

“Considering that this legislative session ends in approximately 20 days, it does not give us much time,” President Shelly said. “I respectfully request that this committee no longer delay and act on this matter.”

The first Committee on Compacts meeting convened on Jan. 22, and was scheduled as an education meeting focused on public comments. During that round of discussions, many pueblo leaders aired their grievances about the Navajo Nation Gaming Compact.

The common thread through all the public comments was the Navajo Nation’s five casinos and language on the population measure for the number of

casinos a tribe could have.

During both hearings, President Shelly stressed the importance of the gaming compact to the Navajo Nation and reminded the Committee on Compacts that they approved and moved the 2013 compact to the floor by a vote of 11-4 on March 11, 2013.

“The Navajo Nation worked tirelessly on the 2013 gaming compact and we were very disappointed that it was not placed on the Senate floor for a vote,” President Shelly said.

After the 2013 legislative session, the Nation met with DOI to discuss the 2013 compact. Under provisions in IGRA, DOI is the final authority for approval of tribal state gaming compacts.

From those discussions with DOI and Interim Legislative Committees, free play, Class II gaming and the condition that the Nation will have to pay any debts to the state before the execution of the gaming compact were all raised as issues.

“Taking all of these factors into account, the Navajo Nation made the decision to request amendments to address the concerns of the Department of the Interior and the State Legislature,” he said.

Amendments to the 2014 compact either removed or amended the provisions of those three issues. Specifically, the free play formula was removed and the accounting methods of free play will be conducted in accordance with Generally Accepted Accounting Principles and the National Indian Gaming Commission Standards.

Amendments to the 2014 compact also removed any reference to Class II gaming.

Finally, the 2014 compact amended Section 9B by stipulating that the state will continue to have a remedy on any payment claims of the 2001 compact, as long as the state provides notice within two years after the effective date of the gaming compact.

“We are neighbors and we need to foster the government-to-government relationship between the State of New Mexico and the Nation,” President Shelly said. “As two sovereign and independent governments, we must be respectful to the positions, concerns and struggles that the Nation and New Mexico face.

“The Navajo Nation has given its best good faith efforts to negotiate and present a compact to the state that is in the best interest for our Navajo people, New Mexicans and economic development,” he added.

The third and final meeting of Committee on Compacts will take place on February 5, beginning at 10 a.m. in Room 322 of the State Capitol in Santa Fe, New Mexico to consider and take action the Navajo Nation Gaming Compact.

The New Mexico Legislative Session ends at noon on February 20, 2014.

“We are neighbors and we need to foster the government-to-government relationship between the State of New Mexico and the Navajo Nation.”

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
One Response
  1. Frederick Kanesewah 5 years ago
WP Facebook Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com